A Great Illustration of Why America’s Schools Are Failing

One of my classmates spent a year teaching at a school in Zimbabwe before he attended business school.

One day, a student’s parent approached him and said, “You are a very bad teacher.”

Dumbfounded, he asked why.

He never expected to hear what the man had to say next.

Apparently, my friend was not a good teacher because he did not beat his students when they misbehaved.

Violence for violence’s sake is not conducive to a positive learning environment. That said, a school that prevents teachers from enforcing discipline also sets barriers to effective education.

The video above shows that even in a case where a student clearly physically threatens a teacher, the school system immediately blames the teacher when she defends herself.

I am not calling for more teacher-on-student violence in schools. I am only calling for more teacher discretion in enforcing discipline.

If keeping order in the classroom involves some judicial application of physical coercion, so be it.

About Sean Patrick Hazlett

Finance executive, engineer, former military officer, and science fiction and horror writer. Editor of the Weird World War III anthology.
This entry was posted in Education, Media, Policy, Politics and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to A Great Illustration of Why America’s Schools Are Failing

  1. Vern R. Kaine says:

    I agree. I went to school with a teacher who literally threw a desk at you if you got way out of line. (Not kidding – this woman was a butcher’s wife). At the very least, it got our attention which was the starting point for learning.

  2. Chris Van Trump says:

    Teachers today operate under something rather the reverse of the Spider-Man mantra: “With no power, comes great responsibility”.

    As time has progressed, particularly since the No Child Left Behind act, more and more of the burden of education has been shifted to the teacher’s shoulders, while at the same time many of the teacher’s abilities to enforce discipline and performance have been stripped away.

    Progress has been made under NCLB, of course, but the stated goals of the act are thoroughly unattainable, and Obama’s Race to the Top program misses the mark just as badly.

    Solving the situation is not as simple as enforcing high-stakes accountability on teachers, and throwing money at schools.

    Because sometimes, the teacher has a student that cannot be disciplined, cannot be taught, with parents who cannot be bothered.

    And sometimes, schools will spend $2,000,000 installing a camera system in the cafeteria to see what the kids are eating.

  3. jlhartman says:

    I was just thinking about this issue yesterday, although it was with respect to the penal system instead of education. It occurred to me how averse America is to the idea of physical punishment, but there’s something lovely about the way nature tells someone to not to touch hot coals or run headlong into a brick wall. The feedback is immediate, memorable, and highly unpleasant. I’m not saying teachers should be allowed to physically strike students, but I wonder how much money we would save if we adopted Singapore’s policy of caning convicted criminals and setting them free instead of paying a starting teacher’s salary to feed, clothe, house, and guard each one of them annually. I assume you saw this? http://bigthink.com/ideas/38573

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.